The messianic secret in the doctrine of mark the disciple. The messianic secret many times in the book of mark, jesus makes a request that can seem baffling. This book will be of special interest to new testament scholars, scientists of religion, theology students and clergy. It was written in greek for a gentile audience, probably in rome, although galilee, antioch thirdlargest city in the roman empire, located in northern syria, and southern syria have also been suggested. Raisanen incisively criticises those who seek to understand marks story world without reference to marks real life concerns. While we may have had to wait until the end of marks story for the denouement of the secrecy gospel, luke removes all suspense early on with the scene in the nazareth synagogue luke 4. For anyone familiar with rebbe nachman and bratslav hasidism, zvi mark s book the scroll of secrets. Finally raisanen considers why mark developed the secrecy motif.
Mark has gotten access to a secret scroll guarded by bratslav hasidism for twohundred years, containing the prognostications of rebbe nachmans regarding the coming of the messiah. The fact that marks gospel was first does not make it more accurate in any particular way. This theme is prevalent throughout the book of mark, but one of the best examples is mark 8. It seems as if everything that happens in marks gospel happens quickly, immediately and then on to the next. But jesus did not want to let very many people know that he was the promised christ.
The messianic secret involves wredes explanation for jesus wanting to hide his identity from his enemies by commanding the disciples to keep silent about his mission on earth and the miracles he performed. Pdf a brief introduction to the messianic secret in mark reed. The messianic secret is the name given to the peculiar way in which marks gospel contains many references to jesus trying to keep his actions and his identity secret. The whole messianic secret theme was always a bit weird and the usual christian explanations never really made sense.
Mark s gospel is a simple, succinct, unadorned, yet vivid account of jesus ministry, emphasizing more what jesus did than what he said. Messianic secret holman bible dictionary bible dictionary. Mysterious people dressed in white disappear just as soon as they. So far as the messianic secret is involved, therefore, mark is not concerned with bringing together a historical jesus and a christ of faith in either of the ways in which this problem is conceived.
New testament commentary, brigham young university, p. Jesus suppression of publicity concerning his messiahship. In other words, he seems to be trying to keep the fact that he is the messiah from the general public. Early christian tradition attributes it to the john mark mentioned in acts, but scholars generally reject this as an attempt to link. Wrede concludes by acknowledging that the notion that mark invented the messianic secret is quite impossible. Referred to by scholars as the messianic secret, jesus frequently asks for his. The concept of a messianic secret was an invention of william wrede back in 1901.
The messianic secret in mark heikki raisanen, heikki. The gospel of mark has for many years been discussed under the question of the messianic secret. In exploring the messianic secret in marks gospel, john perry shows the reader how to distinguish between the actual history of jesus and marks messianic secret theology. Using mark s gospel, give one example of his artistry in writing the story of jesus. But its not the view held by many scholars who have studied marks messianic secret.
This is commonly referred to as the messianic secret. Wredes revolutionary claim about the messianic secret. At several points in the markan narrative, a person identifies christ as the messiah only to have christ instruct them to keep it a secret, though they dont always. A brief introduction to the messianic secret in mark. Raisanen, the messianic secret in marks gospel 15 william wrede, the messianic secret, p. Referred to by scholars as the messianic secret, jesus frequently asks for his identity to be hidden. He even charged the apostles to tell no one that he was the christ matt. The general theme is that jesus in the gospel of mark appears to modern eyes to be hesitant to let others know of his divinity, telling people not to. This continued interest is primarily due to the problems which wrede raised concerning the interpretation of the text of mark in its present form 2.
Mark moves quickly from one episode in jesus life and ministry to another, often using the adverb immediately see note on 1. Before giving some inspirationcompatible reasons for jesus messianic secret, lets recognize that jesus messianic identity is not always presented in a masked way. Ultimately, matthews gospel proves to be less supportive, although not irreconcilable with marks messianic secret. One of the interesting aspects of mark is its use of a literary device called the messianic secret. In order to answer this question, we have to look at the common. Mark is often noted by biblical scholars for its air of immediacy and secrecy, sometimes referred to as markan secrecyurgency or the messianic secret. The blind men of mark inside the messianic secret in the. Jesus guarding of his identity for most of his earthly ministry is typically referred to as the messianic secret. The sequence of related events begins with possible the most important healing story in the text of mark, the account of the blind man who has his sight restored by jesus in a peculiar manner. Wrede claimed that jesus did not ever think he was the messiah and that mark and the rest of the new testament authors sensationalized jesus and made him into the messiah. According to a survey of the new testament mark wrote to. Raisanen, the messianic secret in marks gospel 17 morna hooker, the gospel according to st. And since the secret is the point at issue for the whole gospel, we must say that the problem.
One explanation is that jesus did not want to be confused with a political messiah. What is the significance of the messianic secret in the. Demons demonstrated that they recognized jesus immediately. Throughout his ministry, jesus was very guarded about who would know that he was the messiah see mark 3. For example, when demons declare that jesus is the son of god in mark 3. Numerous speculations are offered to explain this oddity. The secrecy motif is used to downplay those aspects of jesus identity or biog raphy that mark does not find particularly helpful.
For example, we discussed the two times the word torn apart is used in mark s gospel, its significance for mark s overall purpose. And there are a host of scholarly opinions, over a 100 years now of scholarship, about what is. Pdf a brief introduction to the messianic secret in mark. Many times in the book of mark, jesus makes a request that can seem baffling. Wredes primary concern in his discussion of mark is the doctrine of the messianic secret, the notion of a jesus who, assuming messiahship at. The messianic secret motif in mark is a theory which gained currency with a writer named wrede earlier last century and has expanded in various directions according to theorists picking it up. The story of the storytellers the gospel of mark from. He was musing about the passages especially in mark where jesus commands his followers and demons to silenceto not tell people about his messianic mission. But the concept that mark was trying to explain the lack of acknowledgement of jesus messiahship is the missing piece in the puzzle. According to such scholars as william wrede and heikki raisanen, the messianic secret is the idea that markor a later editor of his gospelinvented the. This is a new and original study of mark which challenges several important currently held views. This is clear in johns gospel where jesus makes explicit his messianic identity to the woman at the well john 4. One could also discuss the connections between the story of legion and the last scene, mark 16. Messianic secret refers to the motif, chiefly in the gospel of mark, in which jesus is presented as suppressing knowledge of his identity.
Commentary many times in the book of mark, jesus makes a request that can seem baffling. It is not possible to trace how jesus became during his ministry increasingly conscious of his messianic status. Zugleich ein beitrag zum verstandnis des markusevangeliums. A brief summary of the messianic secret by william wrede.
We see this scenario repeated, especially in marks gospel. About a hundred years ago, the german scholar william wrede published a book called, the messianic secret. One of the keys to understanding the portrayal of jesus in marks narrative lies in the order of stories that follow jesus question in mark 8. The messianic secret is a motif in marks gospel wherein jesus exhibits behavior that appears to be aimed at selfconcealment.
The messianic secret, which one century on is still the point of departure for all studies of the gospel of mark and of an understanding of the literary methods of the gospel writers, is now available in english in this translation by j. To our way of thinking, it would seem that jesus would want everyone to know about the miracle. To someone who does not understand scripture or christian theology, the words of jesus seem strange. The individual conceptions occur in a multiplicity of variants. I highly recommend this book to any serious student of the gospels. Discuss the messianic secret in the gospel of mark in the. Wrede, a german scholar, the messianic secret motif was a literary and apologetic device by which the christological faith of the early church could be reconciled with the fact that jesus never claimed to be the messiah. Mark, however, used the messianic secret to organize his story around the progressive revelation of the person of christ and the messianic consciousness of the disciples. The messianic secret in marks gospel baker publishing group. The messianic secret refers in marks gospel to the repeated instructions of jesus to his followers, those he healed, and sometimes even to demons, not to tell others about him or the. Several times jesus commanded those he healed to tell no one about the miracles see mark 1. Nachman of breslav, does not contain too many surprises. At several points in the markan narrative, a person identifies christ as the messiah only to have christ instruct them to keep it a secret, though they dont always follow his command. At this point we should ask ourselves why jesus was so careful to keep his identity hidden.
Jesus the misunderstood messiah in the gospel of mark. This is a controversial topic that is a hidden underlying theme in the book of mark. Other articles where messianic secret is discussed. This lesson serves to introduce students to the concepts of messiah, messianism, and the secret messiah. The opening chapter examines the whole question of the methodology in the study of marks gospel, especially recent literary approaches. The messianic secret posted on may 31, 2018 may 25, 2018 20. The messianic secret is the notion that jesus was trying to keep his identity as the messiah, a secret. The book as a whole is characterized as the beginning of the gospel. In mark the secrecy of the revelations is essential. It is generally agreed that marks gospel is a theological interpretation born out of the churchs post.
The book theorized as to why jesus repeatedly told those whom he had healed to tell no one anything. Raisanens book 17ze messianic secret in marks gospel. It was observed by william wrede in 1901 that the inconsistencies in the narrative about jesus in mark render incredible some accounts of the life of jesus. In biblical criticism, the messianic secret refers to a motif primarily in the gospel of mark in which jesus is portrayed as commanding his followers to maintain. The messianic secret in marks gospel 9780567292537 by heikki raisanen. Wrede claimed that jesus did not ever think he was the messiah and that mark and the rest of the new testament authors sensationalized. Wrede says that in marks gospel, the entire life of jesus is shot through with the various motifs of this idea. Why did jesus command people to not tell others of the. Exploring the messianic secret in marks gospel john michael perry on.
434 1292 122 1031 139 1301 107 1421 259 64 604 158 708 1066 1235 1206 1029 901 1066 815 778 80 1146 355 952 297 1351 1197 148 1354 1046 253 411 1483 1369 99 81 39 953 414